Since 1996 when California legalized medical marijuana, it had become clear that sooner or later the legalization of recreational cannabis will be possible. On the Midterm Election, which took place on November 2, California voters rejected Proposition 19, by that, refusing the legalization of marijuana. Yet referendum revealed that 4,252,931 (more than 46%) people statewide want to change this situation. Proposition 19 or “Regulate, Control and Tax Cannabis Act” was a ballot initiative, which if passed allowed local governments to control marijuana-related activities. The tendency to legalize marijuana started in the 1970s, when many states in the US started to decriminalize cannabis. Perhaps the most conspicuous example of legalization of recreational pot in the World is Netherlands, which has legalized the possession and consumption of small amounts of marijuana in 1972. By this, Dutch legislative authorities aimed to achieve two goals. First, they aspired to reduce the usage of hard drugs, such as heroin, cocaine and methamphetamine. Second, they assumed that it will bring additional tax revenues to the budget. Although the purpose of legalization of recreational cannabis in the US is similar to Dutch, people are concerned about how it would affect the society as a whole.
First of all, a lot of people misunderstand or do not understand at all the purpose of legalization of recreational marijuana. The increasing number of junkies in the State of California pushes the government to take an action in order to decrease this number or at least to stop the growth. Dutch example proves the well-known proverb “forbidden fruit is the sweetest”, meaning that people by their nature desire to get things that are not allowed. According to the US Department of Health and Human Services, in 2001 the lifetime prevalence of marijuana use among people of ages 12 and older in Netherlands was twice less than in the US (Netherlands-17%, the US-36,9%). The same way, the lifetime prevalence of heroin use in 2001 among the same ages in the US was almost as twice as in Netherlands (the US-5,4%, Netherlands-3%)1. Although the Dutch drug policy tolerates consumption and possession of marijuana it allows selling marijuana only in special places, so-called coffee shops. It is illegal to sell more than 5 grams per one transaction. Likewise, the usage is also restricted, it is forbidden to smoke marijuana in public places except coffee shops. Thus, some people believe that the legalization of recreational marijuana would decrease the number of drug addicts in California.
Today, when state and federal governments face serious fiscal deficits, economical recession forces local governments to take measures in order to find other sources of financial income and create new jobs. There is no doubt that the legalization of recreational cannabis would positively affect the economy of California. First, the legalization of marijuana will reduce state’s expenditures on enforcement. Second, it will not only increase tax revenue from legalized sales, but also attract more tourists. According to the study ”The Budgetary Impact of Ending Drug Prohibition”, released by professor Jeffrey A. Miron, who is a senior lecturer in economics at the Harvard University, approximately $8,7 billion of the savings would result from legalization of marijuana. The same study revealed that legalization of marijuana will generate tax revenue of roughly $8,7 billion annually if it were taxed at the same rates as tobacco and alcohol2. However, the law enforcement officials disagree that with legalization of marijuana their daily work would decline. They say that as long as there is a restriction, surely there would be someone who would offend it. Hereby, it is clear that the legalization of marijuana would cause the creation of new jobs and lure tourists thereby, increasing tax revenues, yet it is not lucid if it would decrease regulation expenses.
What would happen if marijuana was legalized? Despite the fact that the reasons for legalization of recreational marijuana are worth the effort, it is still indistinct whether it will benefit the society or engender unexpected effects.
The first possible effect of legalization of recreational cannabis could be the increasing number of traffic accidents. One of the reasons why Proposition 19 did not pass is that it was poorly written. As a matter of fact, the Proposition 19 did not prohibit driving under the influence of marijuana. People are concerned about if the Proposition 19 would turn cars, trucks, buses and other human operated vehicles from our helpers, without which we can not even imagine our lives, to our enemies, violent murderers driven by impaired pot users. For this reason, many organizations such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) opposed the Proposition 19. However, a San Diego DUI (Driving Under the Influence) lawyer Lawrence Taylor claims that California DUI laws should not be applied to marijuana usage because unlike alcohol and many other drugs marijuana does not impair driving. In his claim Taylor bases on two federal studies, one of which concludes, “appears not possible to conclude anything about a driver’s impairment on the basis of his/her plasma concentrations of THC (Tetrahydrocannabinol) and THC-COOH determined in a single sample.”3 Moreover, other experiments showed that drivers under the influence of marijuana tend to drive slower and more carefully than unimpaired drivers, whereas drunk drivers tend to drive faster and more aggressive. Yet, the reality differs from researches, and people are still being killed by marijuana impaired drivers. In this way, regardless to the type of the drug, under the influence of which one drives his car, the society should not allow anybody to be a threat for innocent people.
The second possible effect of legalization of recreational cannabis could be deterioration of health among state residents. First of all, there are many contradictions concerning how marijuana smoking affects the brain. Some researchers believe that cannabis does not cause long-term negative effects on brain cells at all, whereas others are sure that chronic marijuana users might have difficulties with thinking and problemsolving, and problems with learning and memorizing information. This effect could cause the decline in the quality of education or other areas associated with mental work. Second, numerous studies have shown that cannabis smoke contains carcinogens which contributes to growth of epithelial cells in the lungs tissue4. Marijuana users usually inhale more deeply and hold their breath longer than tobacco smokers, this fact increase the lung’s exposure to carcinogenic smoke. A study of 450 individuals revealed that the people who smoke marijuana frequently but do not smoke tobacco have more health problems and miss more days of work than nonsmokers5. Third, the research says that marijuana increases heart rate by 20-100 % right after smoking; this effect can last up to 3 hours. The same research shows that pot users have a 4.8-fold increase in the risk of heart attack in the first hour after smoking6. This may be due to increased heart rate as well as the effects of marijuana on heart rhythms, causing palpitations and arrhythmias. Thereby, by legalizing cannabis Californians may engender another enemy in the same way as cigarettes to our body and as alcohol to our mind.
In conclusion, the legalization of recreational marijuana definitely will bring many benefits to the people of California, and the Dutch instance clearly proves it; however, those people should understand what kind of effects they might face after its legalization. First, people who analyzed the Dutch Drug Policy and how it affected Dutch society, probably assume that Dutch people and American people have a lot in common. It is possible that after the legalization of marijuana instead of decrease, the number of drug addicts would increase. It is also possible that after pot will be legalized, Mexican drug cartels would increase illegal drug supply, and here we are talking not only about marijuana and hashish but also hard drugs such as cocaine and heroin. This fact surely will force the state government to spend more money in order to control the situation. Second, driving under the influence of any narcotic is dangerous not only for the driver, but also for people who are around, and it does not matter whether one drives fast or slow. Both cases are dangerous because as we all know, moving with the speed which differs from the rest of the traffic makes more chances to get into the traffic accident. Third, if you are a cigarette smoker ask yourself how many times you tried to quit smoking. It is not difficult to stop smoking, but it is very hard not to start over. Marijuana addiction is more severe, and once you have tried to smoke cannabis, it would be difficult for you to refuse to smoke. In a contrast, the fact that consumption of cannabis in recreational purposes is illegal in California does not stop people from using it. People do not afraid to be caught because they know that the worst that can happen to them is that the law enforcement officer will take away their weed. Drivers are not afraid to climb behind the wheel after they smoked the pot because there is no way for the police officer to prove that one is stoned. It is clear that keeping it illegal does not give us control anymore. We should think, maybe it is time to regulate, control and tax cannabis?
Sources:
1: US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, National Household Survey on Drug Abuse: Volume I. Summary of National Findings (Washington, DC: HHS, August 2002), p. 109, Table H.1.
2: Jeffrey A. Miron, Katherine Waldock, “The Budgetary Impact of Ending Drug Prohibition” (Washington, D.C. 2001), p. 1.
3: marijuanaevaluations.com.wordpress.com
4: Tashkin, D.P. Smoked marijuana as a cause of lung injury. Monaldi Arch Chest Dis, 63(2), 92–100, 2005.
5: Polen, M.R., Sidney, S., Tekawa, I.S., Sadler, M., Friedman, G.D. Health care use by frequent marijuana smokers who do not smoke tobacco. West J Med, 158(6), 596–601, 1993.
6: Mittleman, M.A., Lewis, R.A., Maclure, M., Sherwood, J.B., Muller, J.E. Triggering myocardial infarction by marijuana. Circulation, 103(23), 2805–2809, 2001.












